For the first time, a song created by artificial intelligence has topped the Billboard chart. Representatives of the magazine reported this, citing their own statistics. According to Billboard, Walk My Walk, written by the virtual band Breaking Rust, topped last week's Country Digital Song Sales chart. The virtual band debuted at the end of October and generally does not hide its algorithmic origins.
Breaking Rust performs traditional country music, and all of its songs have similar rhythms and chords. The lyrics poke fun at country themes — the AI band sings about beer, pickup trucks, and America. There are no real people on their social media profiles, which are filled with generated images of cowboys and short videos of typical American rural scenes.
Billboard officially recognizes Breaking Rust as an AI band and lists Obier Rivaldo Taylor as the project's creator. This person's identity remains unknown; Taylor's name is only mentioned in connection with the country band and in the context of Defbeatsai, another digital project. It is unclear whether Taylor actually exists.
In any case, the cowboy country project has been successful, as evidenced by Spotify's listening statistics: "Walk My Walk" has been listened to more than three million times, and "Livin' on Borrowed Time" more than four million times.
According to Billboard, Breaking Rust has a monthly audience of over 2 million listeners. Judging by the comments, most listeners are unaware that the content is entirely generated. Users note the "deep voice of the singer" and the emotional component of the compositions.
This situation is reminiscent of a recent story involving another AI project: The Velvet Sundown. The artificial band quickly gained popularity on streaming platforms, sparking heated discussions online. First, people argued about the musicians' origins; then, they debated the acceptability of AI music on streaming services and in the charts. Ironically, the project's authors complained about the flood of fake news about their "band," which negatively affected their image.
The situation with Velvet Sundown turned out to be quite strange. The band was accused of being an AI creation, yet the author of this AI band tried to refute these rumors on the official social media pages. Someone claiming to be the band's manager tried contacting our SoundGale editorial team via work email, demanding we refute Velvet Sundown's AI involvement. We didn't respond. It's obvious to everyone that Velvet Sundown is an AI creation.
Unlike The Velvet Sundown, whose music is generated on Suno and Udio, Breaking Rust's music appears to have been created outside these popular services. It is assumed that the country band is a musical algorithm trained on thousands of similar country hits. Consequently, the program generates variations of the same melody with minimal differences and a voice typical of country music.
Critics have called the band a striking example of AI slop, or neural network garbage. This term describes monotonous, repetitive content created by neural networks that lacks meaning and emotion. Nevertheless, slops rank well in recommendation algorithms because they are specifically adapted for them.
According to Billboard, to reach the top of the Country Digital Song Sales chart, which measures the popularity of country songs on digital platforms, it is enough to accumulate 3,000 plays or downloads. It is unclear whether the 3,000 plays of "Breaking Rust" were real — it is possible that the project's creators used bots and other models to generate the necessary statistics.
Judging by discussions on specialized platforms and resources, such as Reddit, as well as comments in the media, it's clear that the music industry is concerned about the success of the virtual cowboy. While record companies and authors previously worried about copyright violations during model training, the situation has now escalated—not only do algorithms copy music, they also displace live performers from the charts.
VIDEO:
